California Single Payer: Lower Net Cost to Families
January 10, 2022
Summary – Last week saw the release of a tax plan to finance California’s single payer legislation, AB 1400. It was immediately attacked as a tax increase of $12,250 per family. Hey, wait, don’t premiums and cost-sharing disappear under single payer? Yes indeed! The typical family saves money. Health insurance guaranteed, with savings. And no more medical debt or bankruptcy.
ACA-11 Taxes to fund health care coverage and cost control
California Legislative Information
Jan 5, 2022
This measure would impose … taxes at specified rates to fund comprehensive universal single-payer health care coverage … [under AB 1400]
(1) An annual excise tax … upon a qualified business … at a rate of 2.3 percent of the gross receipts … minus the first $2,000,000 in annual gross receipts.
(2) (A) A payroll tax … on every employer who pays … 50 or more resident employees … at a rate of 1.25 percent of wages or other compensation … [plus] 1 percent of wages or other compensation in excess of $49,900 per employee.
(3) (A) … a State Personal Income CalCare Tax:
$149,509 but not over $299,508 0.5% of the taxable income
$299,509 but not over $599,012 1% of the taxable income
$599,013 but not over $1,299,499 1.5% of the taxable income
$1,299,500 but not over $2,484,120 1.75% of the taxable income
$2,484,121 and above 2.5% of the taxable income
California Considers Doubling its Taxes
Tax Foundation
Jan 6, 2022
By Jared Walczak
A proposed constitutional amendment (ACA 11) in California would increase taxes by $12,250 per household …
Comment by: Jim Kahn & Don McCanne
$12,250 per household in new taxes sounds like a lot. This plan includes a 2% payroll tax, a highly progressive income tax (starting at 0.5% at $150,000), and a business excise tax.
However — bottom line — the net savings for a typical middle-class family are highly attractive.
Currently, working families pay a lot for health care:
$5,969 annual employee premium contribution for family coverage
$4,000 annual per household in out-of-pocket spending
That’s $10,000, which under single payer disappears. Huge savings.
Plus, employers contribute $16,253 for premiums for family coverage. That high cost keeps wages low, so if it went away (the proposed payroll tax is about 90% lower), annual wages would rise by $10,000 or more.
Thus, for a working family, we’re into net financial gain territory.
And … the actual tax increase for a middle-class family would be way less than the $12,250 average. That’s because the tax plan relies on a very progressive income tax, $750 at $150,000 and really kicking in above $1 million in annual income.
Overall, single payer reduces costs for the vast majority of families, while providing guaranteed health care.
And: no more medical debts or bankruptcy. That’s a huge boost to financial security.
You might also be interested in...
Recent and Related Posts
Medicare for All Individual Cost Calculator
Political Party Split vs Concurrence on Government Guarantee of Health Care